The problem of quantitative assessment of information trustworthiness in automatic intelligent systems of organizations


Аuthors

Kubrakov D. V.

Moscow Aviation Institute (National Research University), 4, Volokolamskoe shosse, Moscow, А-80, GSP-3, 125993, Russia

e-mail: dvkubrakov@yndex.ru; kubrakovdv@mai.ru

Abstract

The review (subject field, scoping review) considers the current theory and practice of information trustworthiness assessment as one of the sides of information quality. The conducted work (the results of which are shown in this article) is a part of the research on synthesizing methods and algorithms for automatic quantitative assessment of information trustworthiness in automatic intelligent systems. The purpose of the paper is to describe the state of the art of information validity assessment. The task of synthesizing the method of algorithmization of objective quantitative assessment of information trustworthiness is difficult due to the uncertainty of the initial category of reliability, criteria of quantitative assessment, methods and algorithms of assessment and interpretation of assessment results in intelligent information systems. The results of the work consist in formulating generalized descriptions of the practice of applying reliability to the information of traditional and electronic documents, assigning values to the indicator of information trustworthiness, the definition of information reliability and the requirements (criteria) of evaluation to it, and finally, the methods of evaluation of information trustworthiness. Definitions, requirements and methods of information trustworthiness assessment are characterized by semantic scatter. In the definitions of the category of information trustworthiness there is often a substitution of the concept, replacement by separate properties or characteristics of information. As a rule, the trustworthiness of information in existing information systems is assessed by experts, the assessment procedures are poorly formalized and/or described in general terms. The known assessment methods are characterized by narrow areas of application and limited composition of trustworthiness factors.

Keywords:

information quality, information trustworthiness, information reliability factors, assessment (evaluation) of trustworthiness

References

  1. E.A. Smirnov, Development of management decisions: Textbook for universities, Moscow: UNITIDANA, 2002 - 271 p.
  2. A.V. Zobnin, Information and analytical work in state and municipal management, Moscow: Infra-M, 2015 - 120 p.
  3. V. Platt, Information work of strategic intelligence. Basic principles, Moscow: Izdatelstvo Foreign Literature, 1958 - 344 p.
  4. Y.V. Kurnosov and P.Y. Konotopov, Analytica, Moscow: RUSAKI, 2004 - 512 p.
  5. I.M. Lyovkin, Theory and Practice of Information and Analytical Work, Moscow: Institute for Advanced Training of Leaders and Specialists of Fuel and Energy Complex, 2011 - 389 p.
  6. Bertino, Elisa & Dai, Chenyun & Kantarcioglu, Murat. (2009). The Challenge of Assu-ring Data Trustworthiness. Cyber Center Publications. 10.1007/978-3-642-00887-0_2.
  7. Moutassem, Benabderrahmane & Djafri, Laouni & Gafour, Abdel-Kader. (2022). Big Data Veracity: Methods and challenges, The 2nd Conference of Artificial Intelligence and Its Applications, 2022, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/361723024 _Big_Data_Veracity_Methods_and_challenges_benabderrahmane_MOUTASSEM _laouni_DJAFRI_Abdel-Kader _GAAFOUR/citations
  8. E.P. Minakov; A.E. Privalov; P.Yu. Bugaichenko Method of the estimation of the characteristics of the digital models of the cyber-physical systems on the basis of the multiple regression analysis of the results of their application (in Russian) // Proc. of MAI. 2023. № 131. DOI: 10.34759/trd-2023-131-19
  9. A.S. Bukiryov Method of diagnostics of the aircraft onboard equipment complex on the basis of the machine learning (in Russian) // Proc. of MAI. 2023. № 133. URL: https://trudymai.ru/published.php?ID=177672
  10. T.A. Basharina; D.P. Shmatov; S.E. Glebov; I.V. Akolzin Investigation of a jet-centri-fugal nozzle of a sprinkler system of a nuclear power plant by a computational experiment on the basis of a mathematical model taking into account the dispersion of the medium (in Russian) // Proceedings of MAI. 2023. №132. URL: https://trudymai.ru/published.php?ID=176844
  11. V.A. Bogachev; N.A. Markachev; Yu.A. Petrov; M.N. Roshchin; D.V. Sergeev; A.O. Shtokal Wear-resistant and antifriction materials and coatings used in the friction units of the spacecraft structural elements produced by NPO Lavochkin JSC // Proceedings of MAI. 2023. № 132. URL: https://trudymai.ru/published.php?ID=176841
  12. I.N. Kuznetsov, INFORMATION: Collection, Protection, Analysis. Textbook on information-analytical work, Moscow: Yauza, 2001 - 318 p.
  13. I.M. Levkin, S.Y. Mikadze Extraction and processing of information in business intelligence. - SPb: ITMO University, 2015. - 460 с.
  14. Nazri, K.M. & Kamalrudin, Massila & Zaki, Ahmad & Sidek, Safiah. (2016). Verification on the trustworthiness of information: A study. Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology. 92(1):72-80.
  15. M.V. Kirsanova, Modern office management: Study guide. - 3rd ed. - M.: INFRA-M; Novosibirsk: Sibirskoe Accord, 2003. - 304 с.
  16. M.Y. Monakhov [et al], Models for ensuring the reliability and availability of information in information and telecommunication systems: a monograph, Vladimir Gos. Univ. of Russia. A.G. and N.G. Stoletov.-Vladimir: Izd. vlSU,2015.-208с.
  17. Savkin M. A., Determination of reliability of information of DB of municipal ACS, 2000, Moscow, dissertation of candidate of technical sciences, Automated control systems. - Moscow, 2000. - 137 с.
  18. A.I. Afonichkin Research and development of methods of information quality assessment, Dissertation of Candidate of Technical Sciences, Kazan, 1984. - 249 с.
  19. Primiero, Giuseppe & Ceolin, Davide & Doneda, F.. (2023). A computational model for assessing experts' trustworthiness. Journal of Experimental & Theoretical Artificial Intelligence. 1-32. 10.1080/0952813X.2023.2183272.
  20. S.A. Gorelova The concept of information reliability and its reflection in the international ISO standards=The concept of information reliability and its reflection in the international ISO standards/ S.A.Gorelova // Document management: past, present, future= ecords management: past, present, future: proceedings of the VI international scientific-practical conference in memory of Professor T.V. Kuznetsova, Moscow, RSUHU, November 24-25, 20
  21. N.N. Panchenko Credibility as a communication category, dissertation for the degree of doctor of sciences, Volgograd, 2010, - 400 p.
  22. A.V. Beloedova The category of reliability in modern journalistic texts (theoretical and practical aspects), dissertation of candidate of philological sciences, - Belgorod, 2017, - 246 p.
  23. Assiri, Fatmah (2020). Methods for Assessing, Predicting, and Improving Data Veracity: A survey. ADCAIJ: Advances in Distributed Computing and Artificial Intelligence Journal. 9. 5-30. 10.14201/ADCAIJ202094530.
  24. Lozano, Marianela & Brynielsson, Joel & Franke, Ulrik & Rosell, Magnus & Tj¨ ornhammar, Edward & Varga, Stefan & Vlassov, Vladimir. (2019). Veracity assessment of online data. Decision Support Systems. 129. 113132. 10.1016/j.dss.2019.113132.
  25. Nurse, Jason & Agrafiotis, Ioannis & Goldsmith, Michael & Creese, Sadie & Lamberts, Koen. (2014). Two sides of the coin: measuring and communicating the trustworthiness of online information. Journal of Trust Management. 1. 5. 10.1186/2196-064X-1-5.
  26. University of Southampton. Faculty of physical sciences and engineering. Electro-nics and Computer Science. Trustworthiness of Web Information Evaluation Framework by Jarutas Pattanaphanchai. Thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. July 2014
  27. Sikolia, David, David P. Biros, Marlys J. Mason and Mark D. Weiser. “Trustworthi-ness of Grounded Theory Methodology Research in Information Systems.” (2013).
  28. Wang, Xinlei & Govindan, Kannan & Mohapatra, Prasant. (2010). Provenance-Based Information Trustworthiness Evaluation in Multi-Hop Networks. GLOBECOM - IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference. 1-5. 10.1109/GLOCOM.2010.5684158.
  29. D. N. Markov “An Approach to the Comparison of Operability and Trustworthiness Indicators for Monitoring the State of Information Protection at Facilities” // Information Protection Issues, No. 3, pp. 91-96, 2015.
  30. V.N. Afanasyev, L.B. Vladimirov About one private criterion of AIS efficiency estimation. - Control Systems and Machines, 1974, No.4, P.22-25.
  31. V.S. Sinavina, Estimation of the quality of ACS functioning, Moscow: Ekonomika, 1973.
  32. L.K. Kalishevskaya About the value of documentary information/ L.K. Kalishev-skaya, N.A. Fenina//STI.Ser.2. Information processes and systems.1975, №4.-S.3-9.
  33. A.V. Kuznetsov Automation of information reliability control in documents on paper carriers: dissertation... Candidate of Technical Sciences, Orel, 2012, - 198 p.
  34. T.A. Rudakova Estimation of reliability of accounting and reporting information: toolkit and its main components // International Accounting. 2016. №6 (396). URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/otsenka-dostovernosti-uchetno-otchetnoy-informatsiiinstrumentariy-... (date of circulation: 30.06.2024).
  35. M.P. Dorosh Development of a methodology to improve the reliability of cadastral information in the Unified State Register of Real Estate: dissertation of candidate of technical sciences, Novosibirsk, 2018. - 147 с.
  36. V.V. Gluzdovsky, Improving the quality and reliability of borehole geophysical information processing on the basis of approximation, summation and operational-probabilistic modeling: dissertation of Doctor of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, - Tver, 1991, - 224 p.


Download

mai.ru — informational site MAI

Copyright © 2000-2025 by MAI

 Вход